THE
COUNCIL
OF
THE
CITY
OF
NEW
YORK
OFFICE
OF
COUNCIL
MEMBER
I.
DANEEK
MILLER
172-12
Linden
Boulevard
ST.
ALBANS,
NEW
YORK
11434
(718)
776-3700
October
16,
2014
**FOR
IMMEDIATE
RELEASE**
Contact:
Ali
Rasoulinejad,
Office:
(212)
788-7084
Cell:
(646)
300-3153,arasoulinejad@council.nyc.gov
***PRESS
RELEASE***
Elected
Officials
Call
on
MTA
to
Remove
Anti-Islamic
Advertisements
Yesterday,
thirty-four
elected
officials
including
Public
Advocate
Letitia
James,
Council
Member
I.
Daneek
Miller,
the
lone
Muslim
member
of
the
City
Council,
and
thirty
two
other
council
members
sent
a
letter
to
Metropolitan
Transportation
Authority
President
Tom
Prendergast
(attached)
calling
for
the
removal
of
anti-Islamic
advertisements
which
were
recently
placed
and
are
currently
displayed
on
MTA
property.
The
three
ads,
which
have
been
approved
and
paid
for
by
the
American
Freedom
Defense
Initiative,
features
headlines
touting
“Islamic
Jew-Hatred”,
slogans
which
seek
to
equate
Muslim-American
organizations
to
foreign
terrorists
and,
previously,
a
caption
reading
“Yesterday’s
moderate
is
today’s
headline”
while
juxtaposing
images
of
a
young
Muslim
musician
and
an
ISIS
executioner
standing
over
James
Foley.
The
elected
officials,
including
every
member
of
the
Council’s
Progressive
Caucus
and
their
co-Chairs
(Antonio
Reynoso
and
Donovan
Richards),
the
Chair
of
the
Council’s
Jewish
Caucus
(Mark
Levine),
and
the
co-chairs
of
the
Council’s
Black,
Latino
and
Asian
Caucus
(Rosie
Mendez
and
Andy
King),
note
in
the
letter
that
the
“ads
sow
hate,
create
discord,
and
promote
violence
against
Muslims
and
those
who
appear
to
be
Muslim”.
Citing
the
MTA’s
viewpoint-neutral
advertisement
policies,
the
officials
claim
that
“the
MTA
is
well
within
its
legal
authority
to
remove
the
ads
in
part,
and
reject
additional
advertisements”.
They
also
note
that
transit
systems
and
courts
in
other
states
have
rejected
similar
advertisements
such
as
these,
which
the
American
Freedom
Defense
Initiative
(AFDI)
sought
to
have
placed
in
public
spaces.
With
hate
crimes
up
throughout
the
City,
particularly
against
Muslim
and
Jewish
communities
due
to
overseas
turmoil,
the
officials
write
that
“[b]y
approving
these
ads,
the
MTA
is
complicit
in
allowing
the
defamation
and
victimization
of
the
Muslim
community”
and
that
“It
is
[the
MTA’s]
responsibility
to
provide
a
safe
environment
for
all
riders
and
workers”.
Following
the
letter’s
release,
the
officials
submitted
the
following
statements:
“These
ads
are
patently
offensive
and
have
no
place
in
our
city.
They
teach
hatred,
prejudice
and
bigotry
while
doing
nothing
to
foster
dialogue
and
respect.
At
a
time
when
hate
crimes
–
particularly
against
Muslim,
Sikh
and
Jewish
New
Yorkers
–
are
on
the
rise,
we
cannot
condone
the
MTA
permitting
such
advertisements.
I
strongly
encourage
the
MTA
to
reconsider
its
policies
and
reject
advertisements
from
groups
that
preach
hate,”
said Public
Advocate
Letitia
James.
“We
as
a
City
Council,
while
we
recognizing
first
amendment
rights,
absolutely
demand
zero
tolerance
when
it
comes
to
these
provocative
advertisements.
It
is
appalling
that
these
messages
have
been
allowed
and
continue
to
remain
posted.”
said Council
Member
I.
Daneek
Miller.
“As
the
lone
Muslim
member
of
the
Council,
I
find
the
ads
particularly
offensive
and
not
a
true
representation
of
the
Muslim
community,
which
continues
to
be
a
great
contributor
to
our
City.
We
hope
that
the
MTA
will
meet
this
challenge
and
remove
these
ads,
which
only
seek
to
incite
and
provoke,
and
are
not
in
the
best
interests
of
our
great
City.”
“A
platform
as
visible
as
the
MTA
is
no
place
to
propel
hate
speech.
The
Progressive
Caucus
condemns
AFDI's
islamophobic
ads
that
perpetuate
dangerous
stereotypes
and
threaten
New
Yorkers,”
said Progressive
CaucusCo-Chairs
Donovan
Richardsand
Antonio
Reynoso.
“Residents,
commuters
and
tourists
should
experience
a
positive
and
inclusive
environment,
not
the
hostile
one
that
these
ads
provoke.”
"Hiding
behind
the
veil
of
the
first amendment
to
spew
hate
is
pure
cowardice,”
remarked Council
Member
Mark
Levine,
Chair
of
the
Jewish
Caucus. “It's
shocking
and
upsetting
that
the
MTA's
policies
force
them
to
allow
for
such
an
incendiary
anti-Muslim
ad
on
our
busses
and
in
our
subway
stations.
These
types
of
propaganda
only
divide
us
and
ratchet
up
already
increasing
animosity.
The
ads
must
come
down."
“As
one
of
the
most
diverse
cities
in
the
country
and
the
world,
it
is
incredibly
important
that
we
do
not
spread
or
promote
hatred
in
any
form.
The
slanderous
and
bigoted
ads
that have
been
plastered
on
subway
stations
and
on
buses
have
no
place
in
our
city,”
said Council
Member
Corey
Johnson. “I
will
continue
to
speak
out
against
racism
and
religious
discrimination
in
all
its
forms.”
"AFDI's
hateful
rhetoric
threatens
to
incite
acts
of
violence
that
would
harm
the
peace
and
safety
of
my
district's
South
Asian
and
Muslim
residents,”
said Council
Member
Ruben
Wills.
“It
is
not
welcome
anywhere
in
our
state,
especially
Southeast
Queens.
I
join
my
colleagues
in
calling
on
the
MTA
to
remove
these
vulgar
ads,
and
prohibit
them
from
being
displayed
in
the
future."
“The
American
Freedom
Defense
Initiative’s
advertisements
are
inflammatory
and
promote
an
anti-Islamic
message,”
noted Council
Member
Andrew
Cohen.
“While
I
believe
wholeheartedly
in
the
freedom
of
speech,
I
do
not
believe
that
hate
messages
should
be
transported
–
quite
literally
–
through
the
public
transit
system.
New
York
City's
subway
system
serves
to
connect
our
many
ethnically
diverse
neighborhoods
across
the
city.
It
is
no
place
for
prejudice
and
we
cannot
allow
advertisements
promoting
prejudice
on
the
subways.”
“No
amount
of
revenue
is
worth
the
ill
feelings
that
these
advertisements
will
engender.
We
should
be
able
to
live
in
a
City
that
is
free
of
discrimination
and
an
enforcement
of
stereotypes
that
communities
are
affected
by
on
a
daily
basis,”
said Council
Member
Rosie
Mendez.
“The
displaying
of
offensive
ads,
which
target
the
Muslim
community,
should
not
be
tolerated
by
the
Metropolitan
Transit
Authority
(MTA),”
added Council
Member
Inez
D.
Barron.
“As
elected
officials
we
have
a
responsibility
to
promote
peace
and
condemn
violence
in
all
forms.”
“New
York
City
is
a
reflection
of
the
rich
cultural
diversity
that
exists
globally.
The
United
States
of
America
was
founded
on
several
core
principles,
ranging
from
freedom
of
speech
to
freedom
of
religious
belief.
While
both
are
sacred
treasures
of
what
we
hold
dear
as
Americans,
we
are
also
mindful
of
how
all
of
these
rights
are
interconnected.
One’s
freedom
of
speech
should
not
impede
on
one’s
right
of
religion.
Since
September
11th,
rhetoric
against
members
of
the
Muslim
faith
has
heightened.
We
can
never
allow
the
heinous
actions
of
a
few
to
cast
a
shadow
on
the
larger
demographic
of
law-abiding
Muslim-Americans.
The
recent
decision
by
the
Metropolitan
Transportation
Authority
to
publish
anti-Islamic
advertisements,
which
can
incite
additional
hate
crimes
in
a
city
known
for
its
rich
diversity
and
tolerance,
is
a
step
in
the
wrong
direction.
We
can
never
allow
public
space
or
encourage
the
use
of
private
space
to
be
used
to
defame
members
of
our
society,”
said Council
Member
Laurie
A.
Cumbo.